CA FOUNDATION CASE STUDIES - QUESTION SET 2
INDIAN CONTRACT ACT, 1872 | SALE OF GOODS ACT, 1930 INDIAN PARTNERSHIP ACT, 1932 | COMPANIES ACT, 2013
- X, a coolie in uniform carried Y’s luggage from the railway platform to taxi without being asked by Y to do so. Y does not make any attempt to stop X from carrying the luggage. Is Y bound to make payment to X? A Railway passenger receives a ticket on the face of which is printed "this ticket is issued subject to rules/regulations/conditions contained in the current timetable of the railways". Comment on whether he is bound by these terms.
- A minor fraudulently misrepresented his age to Mr X, a moneylender and executes a mortgage deed for Rs.20,000. The minor subsequently denies his liability on the deed. Comment.
- S brought tyres from Dunlop Rubber Co Ltd and sold them to D, a sub-dealer, who agreed not to sell them below Dunlop's list price and to pay the Dunlop Co. 5 $ as damages on every tyre D undersold. D sold two tyres at less than the list price and thereupon Dunlop Co Ltd sued him for the breach.
- ‘A’ is in dire need of Rs.1,00,00 but was unable to get any loan from banks as he had no security to offer. ‘A’ approached his friend ‘B’ who knowing the helpless position of a lent money at a very high rate of interest, said that he had himself borrowed money from ‘C’. The contract is: A) Vitiated by the undue influence that we had exercised over a due to his close friendship B) void as the rate of interest being very high was unconscionable C) not valid as ‘B’ had wrongly misled it that he had borrowed money from C D) n valid as a friend could not be supposed to have wielded undue influence only because the money lent carried a higher rate of interest.
- ‘A’ entered into a contract that he shall give his house to ‘B’ for rent. They further agreed that if ‘B’ uses the house for gambling, the rent shall be charged at the rate of Rs.50,000 per month and if the house is used for residential purposes that the rent shall be charged at the rate of Rs. 10,000 per month. Is the contract valid?
- Sarvesh sells the goodwill of a shop to Vikas for ₹.10 lakhs and promises not to carry on such business forever and anywhere in India. Comment.
- A agrees to pay B Rs.5000 if he marries C. She dies before the marriage. Can we recover the amount?
- A owes B two sums, one for Rs.1000 which is barred by limitation and another for Rs. 1500 which is not barred by the limitation of time. A pays B Rs.500 on account generally. B later sues A for Rs. 1500. A pleads that the amount of debt outstanding to B is Rs.1000 on account of the settlement of Rs.500 against a debt of Rs.1500 and the earlier debt of Rs.1000 now being time-barred cannot be realised. Comment on the plea of A.
- A contracted with B to supply him (B) 500 tonnes of iron and steel @ Rs.5000 per ton, to be delivered at a specified time. Thereafter, A contracts with C for the purchase of 500 tonnes of iron steel at Rs.4800 per ton, and at the same time told C that he did so, for the purpose of performing his contract entered into with B. she failed to perform his contract in due course, consequently, he could not procure any iron and steel and B rescinded the contract. What would be the number of damages which he could claim from C in the circumstances? Explain with reference to provisions of the Indian contract act, 1872.
- A agrees to sell two of his cars to B at a price to be fixed by C. He immediately gives delivery of the first car. C refuses to fix the price. He asked for the return of the car already delivered while B claims the delivery of the second car too. Decide.
- D bought a colour TV from M/S Kaka Enterprises for a sum of Rs.40,000. The TV set was defective right from the beginning and it did not work in spite of repairs by the expert mechanics. What is the remedy available to D?
- A offered to sell to B a certain machine for Rs.50,000. B refused to buy it unless certain work was done on it to put it into a running condition. He agreed to do the same but while the machine was being repaired, it was destroyed without the fault of any person. Can you recover the price from B?
- Ashu of Bombay enters into an agreement with Jai of New Delhi to supply five motorcycles to be delivered to the latter at New Delhi. Ashu sends these motorcycles through M/S Deep transport Ltd, a leading transporter. At the motorcycle reaches New Delhi on time but Jai delays to take delivery. M/S Deep transporter informed Jai that the motorcycles are lying at their godown at Jai’s risk. Before taking the delivery of these motorcycles, Jai becomes insolvent. Ashu wants to exercise his right of stoppage of goods in transit under the sale of goods act. Advice.
- A, B and C are partners in a firm carrying on money lending business. D, a customer, deposit his jewellery with the firm for safe custody. A and B sell this jewellery and misapprirate the money C, being a sleeping partner has no knowledge about the sale. D filed a suit against all the three partners. Can C we had liable? Give reasons.
- A B and C are partners of a partnership firm ABC and company. The firm is a dealer in office furniture. A was in charge of purchase and sale, B was in charge of maintenance of accounts of the firm and C was in charge of the handling of all legal matters. Recently through an agreement between them, it was decided that A will be in charge of maintenance of accounts and B will be in charge of purchase and sale. Being ignorant about such agreement, M, supply and supplied some furniture to A, who ultimately sold him to a third party. Referring to the provisions of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, advise whether M can recover the money from the firm. What will be your advice in case M was having knowledge about the agreement?
- X entered into a partnership in an existing firm RST associates for a period of 10 years and paid Rs.5 lakhs as a premium. The firm was dissolved after the expiry of three years because of the insolvency of a partner. X now claims the refund of the premium. Advise X as to his rights. Would your answer be different if the firm is dissolved on account of the misconduct of X?
- The articles of association of XYZ Ltd provides that the board of directors has the authority to issue bonds provided such issues are authorised by the shareholders by a necessary resolution in the general meeting of the company. The company was in dire need of funds and therefore it issued the bonds to Mr X without passing any such resolution in the general meeting. Can Mr X recover the money from the company? Besides, referring to the relevant provisions of the Companies Act, 2013.
- Krishna, an assessee, was a wealthy man earning huge income by way of dividends and interest. He formed three private companies and agreed with each to hold a block of investment as an agent for them. The dividend and interest income received by the company was handed back to Krishna as pretended loan. This way Krishna divided his income into three parts in a bid to reduce his tax liability. Designed for what purpose the three companies or established? Whether the legal personality of the three companies may be disregarded?
Comments
Post a Comment